Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer

Volume 2, No. 2Volume 2, Issue 2

Published December 1, 2022

Issue description

This issue brings together a diverse set of contributions that explore literature, film, popular culture, and mythology through interdisciplinary critical frameworks. The articles engage with themes such as archetype, myth, national identity, ecological thought, and cultural performance, demonstrating how literary and cultural texts continually reinterpret classical narratives and symbolic structures within contemporary contexts.

Michael Filas examines Safe by Todd Haynes in relation to the social and psychological realities of the COVID-19 pandemic, reading the protagonist’s illness and isolation through Northrop Frye’s concept of Aristotelian tragedy. Soham Mukherjee and Madhumita Roy explore the work of Ismail Kadare, analyzing how Balkan myths are reworked in his fiction to articulate Albania’s national identity and historical experience.

Turning to popular culture, Shuvam Das investigates existential questions of meaning and identity in the manga series One-Punch Man and My Hero Academia, drawing connections with Albert Camus’s philosophical reflections in The Myth of Sisyphus. Similarly engaging with contemporary mythmaking, Kelvin Ke Jinde analyzes the superhero archetype in Marvel Cinematic Universe films, interpreting it through Plato’s concept of the auxiliary class and Joseph Campbell’s theory of the monomyth.

Classical drama and archetypal psychology are addressed by Riccardo Gramantieri, who offers a Jungian interpretation of Henrik Ibsen’s Ghosts, focusing on symbolic representations of illness and the emergence of the Self. Ecocritical and mythological perspectives are explored by Bhishma Kumar and Sovan Chakraborty through a study of the poetry of Mary Oliver, emphasizing the relationship between myth, nature, and posthumanist thought.

Expanding the scope of literary analysis to performance culture, Hampton D. Harmon examines stand-up comedian Bill Hicks as a prophetic archetype, analyzing how comedy functions as a form of cultural critique and ritualized social commentary. The issue concludes with a review article by Stella Chitralekha Biswas on Ahalya by Koral Dasgupta, which reinterprets a well-known mythological narrative from a feminist perspective.

Taken together, the works in this issue highlight the enduring significance of myth, archetype, and narrative structures across literary, cinematic, and cultural forms, illustrating how contemporary scholarship continues to reinterpret traditional motifs within modern intellectual and social frameworks.

Articles

  1. Todd Haynes’s Safe and the Covid-19 Pandemic Mirror on the Wall

    Todd Haynes’s 1995 film Safe depicts the demise of protagonist
    Carol White as she suffers headaches, bloody noses, insomnia,
    asthma, and seizures from environmental illness, which leads to
    her social and marital demise and her taking refuge at Wrenwood,
    a sanitarium retreat in the Albuquerque foothills. This article reads
    Carol as a tragic archetype, and aligns the indices of COVID-19
    pandemic life (face masks and social isolation for safety) with
    Carol’s similar response to her illness. While the film has
    previously been critiqued and interpreted from perspectives
    including feminism, consumerism, environmentalism, suburbia,
    race, heteronormativity, melodrama, plague, Whiteness, and AIDS
    politics, this article performs a close reading based on Northrop
    Frye’s archetypal definition of Aristotelian tragedy, and then
    analyzes the differences in late-pandemic middle class American
    perspectives from that of Carol White as she navigates her
    situation. Late-pandemic middle class perspectives provide an
    optimistic and alternate fate to the tragic pathos depicted in Carol’s
    story.

  2. Ismail Kadare’s Usage of Myth in Comprehending Albania’s National Condition

    Albania is a small country located in the Balkan peninsula on the
    Adriatic coast. Its complicated political history and a cultural
    identity that straddles European and Asian makes the nation an
    interesting subject for analysis based on national identity
    structures. Additionally, the nation has a rich oral tradition and
    often claims to have been the birthplace of Homeric poetry.
    Literature from this nation, however, is neither widely read nor
    available. The only Albanian literary export of note is Ismail
    Kadare who was awarded the inaugural Man Booker International
    Prize for his entire body of work and his efforts to bring Albanian
    culture to the global masses. Kadare’s writing style involves
    creating alternate historical timelines, extensive usage of allegory
    and, most significantly for this collection, the usage, re-usage and,
    sometimes, reconstruction of Balkan myths.
    This essay will analyse how Kadare uses myths in order to make
    sense of the national condition of Albania from the beginning of
    World War II until the early 2000s when Albania began its process
    of recuperating from the Balkan Wars in the 1990s. Indeed, this is
    not Kadare’s only motivation for writing. He also intends to
    develop a new Albanian identity that is separate from its Ottoman
    history. Albania was an Ottoman colony for over four centuries
    and was subsequently occupied and influenced – culturally and
    economically – by new geopolitical powers in Eastern Europe
    such as Yugoslavia and Soviet Russia. In his novels, Kadare recontextualises myths to allegorically critique these foreign powers
    as well as native politicians. In doing so, he attempts to show the
    purity and nobility of authentic Albanian culture despite its
    inherent atavism.

  3. The Symbol of Peace as a Myth: Deconstructing the Existential Problem in One-Punch Man and My Hero Academia

    My Hero Academia and One-Punch Man are popular manga
    series that have amassed a global fanbase. This paper, uses a poststructuralist reading to draw parallels between Albert Camus’
    The Myth of Sisyphus and Japanese superhero manga, examining
    how these works deal with the existential question about the
    meaning of life. It observes that the superhero myth functions
    with the help of several signs that construct a superhero’s
    identity and that these identity markers define their take on the
    existential problem. Furthermore, the paperexamines the role
    played by the crowd—the in-text audience of the myth—in the
    process of mythologization, where they serve as a medium
    between the superheroes and the actual reader.

  4. The Superhero Archetype as an Auxiliary Class in Marvel’s Avengers Movies

    The superhero is a much-maligned figure in contemporary culture.
    In what follows, I draw upon Plato’s idea of the auxiliary class and
    Joseph Campbell’s monomyth to read the superhero as a modern
    version of the auxiliary class. Focusing on the superhero archetype
    that is found in the MCU or Marvel Cinematic Universe movies, I
    argue that the superhero-auxiliary is underpinned by an ethos that
    privileges values like public service, teamwork, social cohesion,
    and self-sacrifice. The significance of this reading lies in showing
    how the MCU re-mythologizes Plato’s auxiliary class for
    contemporary culture. As a corollary to that, I hope that the
    reading will ameliorate some of the negative reception that has
    plagued the superhero archetype in literary and media discourses.

  5. Archetypal Elements in Henrik Ibsen’s Ghosts

    Ghosts is one of Henrik Ibsen’s best-known dramas. The reason
    can also be found in the central theme of the play that caused a
    scandal to its appearance: the luetic disease transmitted from father
    to son. Ibsen does not explicitly declare the pathological
    component but that critics have identified as hereditary
    neurosyphilis. Some critics such as Derek R. Davis in the Sixties
    and Russel E. Brown in the Nineties, proposed a pathology other
    than the luetic one. Starting from the symptoms described by
    Ibsen, they proposed that Osvald was suffering from
    schizophrenia.
    It is difficult to expect a literary character to behave exactly like a
    person. It often represents for the author a symbol or an idea to be
    developed. Therefore, it is not possible to subject a fictitious
    character to a psycho-pathological analysis as if he were a real
    person. However, it is possible to use him as a model and offer a
    different interpretation of the literary work in which he moves.
    That being said, the purpose of this work is to provide further
    support to the schizophrenic theory of Osvald’s illness proposed
    by Davis and Brown, using Jung’s archetypal theory. A
    psychological interpretation can be provided here of what happens
    on stage to the characters in Ghosts and highlight the
    psychological symbol of the emerging Self.

  6. Whiffing the Sense of Place: Breaking the Anthropocene Narrative through Myth in Mary Oliver’s Select Works

    In this paper, we have strived to decode the sense of place in Mary
    Oliver’s select works through the optics of primitive mythology.
    Primitive mythology unveils the primordial human culture and
    human relationship with the non-human world. It silently
    advocates posthumanism, immersive installation, intercorporeality,
    and resists the dyadic approaches of human culture as well as the
    model of two worlds – the human and the non-human. In the
    context of Oliver, we find that she has given primitive myths an
    apt place in her poetry and non-fictional works and has talked of
    how these myths connect human culture to that of nature by
    striking out ego-centric attitudes of Renaissance Humanism. The
    poet has rejected such beliefs that promulgate the schools of
    anthropocentrism, ego-centrism, pseudo-spiritualism/centralism
    and the notion of Self/Other binary. She has rather favored the
    concepts of posthumanism and eco-centrism, which deny any
    privileges given to human beings. We have used the mythological
    concepts of Joseph Campbell, Steven B. Harris and David
    Leeming in this paper.

  7. Laughing Towards Bethlehem: A Critical Reading of Bill Hicks as Prophetic Archetype

    The performative value of standup comedy is in its inclusion of the audience in
    the communicative moment; the audience member, at-home and live, exists as a
    witness to the presentation of the comedian in the involuntary response of
    laughter, an active and realized part of the comedic event. While there has been a
    burgeoning amount of scholarly work surrounding the cultural significance of
    standup comics and the literary implications of their work, there has been very
    little scholarship assessing the work of comedian Bill Hicks, and none regarding
    the final special filmed before his death, Revelations. In a world where a standup
    comic has become the most popular interviewer of all time, and seven of the
    most downloaded twenty-five podcasts in America are hosted by current or
    former standup comedians, the link between the actual comedic event and the
    larger scope of the comic’s influence is clear. Although scholars have correctly
    identified standup comedy as a new literary and rhetorical form directing
    consumers toward cultural and social change, and heterodoxic formulations of
    thought, I will argue that this framework is incomplete. In order to wholistically
    understand the influence of standup comedy on American culture, one must
    correctly identify the religious nature of the comedian’s work and selfpresentation, specifically through the Judeo-Christian concepts of “messiah” and
    “prophet.” Such a framework provides a language for the ritualistic response
    within the prophetic moment, as well as the dual nature or reverence and
    revulsion that consumers have for comedians. These concepts are archetypes,
    and provide new language for interpreting both the work of Bill Hicks and the
    standup comic in general. The comic claims to bear witness to the truth, and the
    member of the audience participates in the prophetic moment by bearing witness
    to the comedian, acting with him in ritualized movement. I will present a case
    study and close reading of Bill Hicks’ televised special Revelations, evaluating
    his comedy as a fulfillment of the prophetic archetype. When the standup comic
    is understood prophetically, and the material understood through the lens of the
    prophetic message, the consumer and the scholar are able to grasp the
    foundations of the larger movement centered around the cultural figure of the
    standup comic beyond the performative work; the larger movements amount to a
    form of religious devotion, and the comic’s social commentary ceases to be
    performative, but transformative. The devotion of acolytes to the extraperformative catalogue of comics like Dave Chapelle, Joe Rogan, and Hannah Gadsby form a larger cultural moment, for which Bill Hicks presented himself as
    a forerunner and prototype.

  8. Ahalya by Koral Dasgupta, Pan Macmillan, 2020, 204 pages

    Ahalya, the first book of the Sati-series by Koral Dasgupta, claims
    to be a re-telling of the well-known mythological account of a
    hapless woman and her plight under the brunt of a patriarchal
    social order. Instead of reiterating the familiar tale of Ahalya’s
    seduction and her consequent cursed fate, the writer chooses to
    focus on the standpoint of the woman who relates the story of her
    own journey towards self-discovery. Elements of memory, history,
    myth and bildungsroman intersect to create an intricately detailed
    narrative that ruptures the demureness and over-emphasis on
    docile chastity associated with the traditional image of the Hindu
    woman. In her attempt to prioritize the voice of the woman,
    Dasgupta almost re-interprets the popular notions of virginity and
    virtue accorded to the five women or panchkanyas of Hindu
    mythology‒Ahalya, Draupadi, Kunti, Tara and Mandodari. It is
    believed that Ahalya, the most beautiful creation of Brahma, was
    punished for no fault of her own, with no scope given to her to
    assert any degree of agency.